Latest Cigar Evaluations
 
 
 
 
Cigar
 
Ashton La Aroma de Cuba Churchill
Ashton La Aroma de Cuba Churchill
Ashton La Aroma de Cuba Churchill

Ashton La Aroma de Cuba Churchill

This cigar is clean, slightly sweet with good complexity and nice hints of fruit (including green banana/plantain) and floral notes. It consistently performs well.
 
 
Cigar Accessory
 
Havana Saver
Havana Saver
Havana Saver

Havana Saver

This is a wonderful, compact, multi-purpose cigar accessory. You should have one by your ashtray to fix draws, hold your cigar when working outside or on the golf course, and to help you smoke a good cigar to the end.

 
 
 
Cigar
 
My Father No. 4 Lancero
My Father No. 4 Lancero
My Father No. 4 Lancero

My Father No. 4 Lancero

A good cigar that is slightly tannic with good complexity, slightly raw/fresh/green flavors, and very good performance overall.
 
 
Cigar
 
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Toro
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Toro
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Toro

My Father Le Bijou 1922 Toro

A fairly strong cigar that is slightly tannic with good complexity, slight raw/fresh/green flavors, and good performance overall.

 
 
 
Cigar
 
Esteban Carreras Chupa Cabra Corona
Esteban Carreras Chupa Cabra Corona
Esteban Carreras Chupa Cabra Corona

Esteban Carreras Chupa Cabra Corona

A good cigar overall with some complexity and pleasant flavors but a few performance issues.
 
 
Cigar
 
Kings Barón Robusto
Kings Barón Robusto
Kings Barón Robusto

Kings Barón Robusto

This cigar performs well, has a pleasant chocolate/coffee complexity, but is slightly papery.

 
 
 
Cigar
 
Ezra Zion Tantrum
Ezra Zion Tantrum
Ezra Zion Tantrum

Ezra Zion Tantrum

An interesting, small, powerful Nicaraguan puro that consistently performed well.
 
 
Cigar
 
CLE EIROA Robusto
CLE EIROA Robusto
CLE EIROA Robusto

CLE EIROA Robusto

A great, well-constructed, very consistent cigar with dry light wood/cedar complexity.

 
 
 
Cigar
 
Davidoff Nicaragua Robusto Tubo
Davidoff Nicaragua Robusto Tubo
Davidoff Nicaragua Robusto Tubo

Davidoff Nicaragua Robusto Tubo

A great Nicaraguan puro that performed very well.
 
 
Cigar
 
La Palina El Diario Toro
La Palina El Diario Toro
La Palina El Diario Toro

La Palina El Diario Toro

A great cigar that has consistently performed well, particularly with aging.

 
 
 
Cigar
 
Casa Fernandez Miami Reserva Maduro Toro
Casa Fernandez Miami Reserva Maduro Toro
Casa Fernandez Miami Reserva Maduro Toro

Casa Fernandez Miami Reserva Maduro Toro

An excellent well-performing cigar with great clean flavors that is smooth and balanced.
 
97
 
 
Cigar Accessory
 
Commonwealth Cedar Spills
Commonwealth Cedar Spills
Commonwealth Cedar Spills

Commonwealth Cedar Spills

A great cedar spill with lots of customization options, it is slightly longer than Cigar Reserve cedar spills but both are long enough to light cigars.

 
 
 
Cigar Accessory
 
Cigar Reserve Cedar Spills
Cigar Reserve Cedar Spills
Cigar Reserve Cedar Spills

Cigar Reserve Cedar Spills

A great sword-shaped cedar spill, slightly smaller than Commonwealth cedar spills but long enough to light cigars.
 
 
Cigar
 
Joya de Nicaragua CyB Lonsdale Club
Joya de Nicaragua CyB Lonsdale Club
Joya de Nicaragua CyB Lonsdale Club

Joya de Nicaragua CyB Lonsdale Club

This is a great cigar and vitola (size) which I have smoked regularly from the time they first came out as the Cuenca y Blanco.
 
97

 
 
 
Cigar
 
Arcangel Churchill
Arcangel Churchill
Arcangel Churchill

Arcángel Churchill

This is an excellent cigar with good complexity and evolves throughout the smoke.
 
 
Cigar
 
Ortega Serie D No. 8 Maduro
Ortega Serie D No. 8 Maduro
Ortega Serie D No. 8 Maduro

Ortega Serie D No. 8 Maduro Box Press Robusto

A remarkable cigar with great Nicaraguan flavors, wonderful balance, and excellent performance.

 
 
 
Cigar Accessory
 
cfmagma-flame
cfmagma-flame
cfmagma-flame

Prometheus Magma T (2011 Limited Edition for CFCF) Lighter

SUMMARY: This is an excellent lighter that is reliable, lights a cigar fast with three flames, has two punch cutters, holds a lot of fuel, has a fuel indicator so you know when you’re low, and it looks and feels great! I ...
 
 
Cigar Accessory
 
424ac-empty
424ac-empty
424ac-empty

XIKAR Portable Ashtray Can

This accessory can be very useful and I liked pretty much everything about it.

 
 
 
Cigar Accessory
 
Stinky Herf Edition Ashtray
Stinky Herf Edition Ashtray
Stinky Herf Edition Ashtray

Stinky Cigar Herf Edition Ashtray

This is the best ashtray I have ever owned. It is well made, functional and works well.
 
 
Cigar
 
601 La Bomba Atomic
601 La Bomba Atomic
601 La Bomba Atomic

601 La Bomba Atomic

This interesting cigar has a long fuse of tobacco extending from the cap, good performance and good classic Nicaraguan flavors overall.